The Secret History of Watergate

John Ehrlichman, UCLA 1948 co-valedictorian (UCLA Archives via California Historian)

As a reporter for UCLA’s Daily Bruin I wrote about a New York Times op-ed published after the 1993 death of H.R. “Bob” Haldeman by fellow UCLA alumnus Clancy Sigal. In the article, Sigal revealed a campus controversy that embroiled Haldeman in the late 1940s, involving a dead dog discovered at his fraternity and the fight he had with the campus newspaper. In his op-ed, Sigal set up a generational rivalry that played out decades later through the Watergate affair that eventually sent Haldeman to prison.

It sounded a little ridiculous until Sigal reminded the reader who his fellow alumni were: John Ehrlichman, Frank Mankiewicz, Alexander Butterfield and Gil Harrison.  Ehrlichman and Butterfield pledged the same fraternity; Mankiewicz and Harrison wrote for the Daily Bruin.  For those who don’t remember their history: Ehrlichman and Haldeman ran the campaigns and White House of Richard Nixon. Mankiewicz ran the campaign of George McGovern against Nixon in 1972 and Harrison the left-liberal New Republic.  Maybe this little dog was no historical pup after all.

I was fascinated. Raised in a politically attuned family with a Watergate obsession – my mother watched the entire hearings when I was barely two years old — during the next few months I elaborated Sigal’s op-ed into a feverish two-part series for the Daily Bruin that won the California Intercollegiate Press Association’s award for best series the following year. I filled out an untold story mostly taken up, in All the President’s Men, by the “dirty tricks” perpetrated by University of Southern California alumni. Nobody had told the UCLA story in such detail.

I talked to Mankiewicz and Haldeman’s widow.  I interviewed (and taped – taped!)  Ehrlichman. I talked to Gil Harrison and his wife.  I talked to Clancy Sigal.  It was a cub reporters’ dream, to uncover the secret history of Watergate.

Filled with an undergraduate’s limitless sense of the possible and one’s own abilities, I then took the series and expanded it.  Behind the uncanny campus connections among the Nixon-McGovern operatives I discovered a common thread.  They had all been cultivated by a woman named Adaline Guenther, known universally as “Grandma,” who ran an interfaith center at UCLA in the 1940s and 1950s and had an extraordinary eye for budding talent. In those days she cultivated Haldeman, Ehrlichman, Harrison, Mankiewicz, and later Tom Bradley, the first African American mayor of Los Angeles – an entire generation of Southern California leaders and intellectuals.

This gave the story both a spine and a tragic thread. Grandma was pure of heart and soul, an absolute idealist, and in her dotage – she had retired by the 1970s – she watched the finest she had cultivated destroy themselves in the most public way imaginable.  I read her oral history and some of her journals and felt her horror as she witnessed, in anonymous privacy, her brightest stars burn out in a blaze of obscenity and paranoia.  It led her, in her last years, to question everything she had ever done with her life.

I was so moved by the example of this selfless, perceptive but forgotten woman – you will find only ephemera about her in a Google search – that I just recently parted with her oral history.  I post my article here (you’ll forgive the editors’ remarks at the end which I did not consent to) in part to preserve her life as well as to add an additional chapter to our understanding of Watergate. Most of these personalities are now dead (Sigal excepted) which makes this story all the more poignant.

The article I wrote didn’t find the outlet I was hoping for – the fairly obscure magazine of the Conference of California Historians – but I post it here because it is not available in any other format other than the few libraries that might have a copy on their shelves.

Westwood to Watergate – California Historian Winter 1999


3 thoughts on “The Secret History of Watergate

  1. The article in California Historian is fascinating. As Daily Bruin editor in 1954, the year of the Administration Directive gutting the editor selection process, I found many echoes of my own campus experience. I came across the article online while researching the Golden Bruin, a mysterious (to me) secretive honor society at UCLA. Were you aware of it? I was invited to join the Golden Bruin in 1954 but walked out on the initiation ceremony in a bizarre incident. Another Bruin alumnus I know is convinced that Granma Guenther and the Golden Bruin are part of the same effort to coopt potential student leaders and funnel some of them to the CIA. I’m glad the Bruin carried on after the disaster of my semester and fostered reporters like you who wrote prize-winning stories.

    • Dear Martin – thank you for finding my article. I’ve indeed not heard of the Golden Bruin and it sounds like you knew Grandma Guenther better than I ever could. But I read her oral history and got access to her papers (both at the UCLA Library) and a CIA or otherwise nefarious connection does sound out of character. I think she was a pure idealist and loved cultivating smart, talented young people – and she was remarkably good at it. It was heart-breaking to read her diary as she watched Haldeman and Ehrlichman debase themselves in the last years of her life. She had a real crisis of faith then. I hope she didn’t die feeling she had wasted her life’s work on those two men considering how much she gave to so many others. As for the Bruin — it’s the best experience I had at UCLA. Everything I have earned since then I owe to the paper, including all my friends from then, who all worked there and still have stories to tell when we get together.

      • Ach, the truth is that I have no recollection of Grandma Guenther, although a photo of her I found on the Internet looks familiar. I did hang out at the University Religious Conference some but don’t remember her there. I remember discussion groups organized by a man but my participation was minor. The DB is also the formative experience of my life. George Garrigues, who wrote the definitive Bruin history, is a contemporary and friend of mine — shot down by Student Council when he was elected managing editor by the staff — and we’re still in touch, along with others from that era. Sadly, a number have died. I’m also in touch with Clancy Sigal although I don’t think we’ve ever met. Clancy was at UCLA with my brother David, who was also a friend of Jim Garst. The Golden Bruin thing is curious. It exists on the Internet in a muffled form. There are even photos of some members, but no names, and when I click on what would be a biography accompanying a picture I get a block of text in Latin that doesn’t seem worth deciphering. I think it’s boilerplate accompanying all the mug shots. I did manage to get a glimpse of a History of the Golden Bruin online that said it was founded by Robert Sproul in 1936 on the model of the Golden Bear, a semi-secret society at Berkeley — which does have a readable website.
        Best regards

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s